National attention is shining on one of Key West’s most distinctive properties. Brenda Donnelly and Brenda Donnelly Real Estate’s featured listing at 1401 Atlantic Blvd., known as The Atlantis House, was highlighted this week by Realtor.com for its rare combination of island charm, investment value, and a story that perfectly captures the spirit of Key West living.
Located steps from Higgs Beach in the sought-after Casa Marina District, the property offers a unique opportunity with two rare transient licenses, multiple curated living spaces, ocean-view decks, private outdoor retreats, and proven vacation rental history. The home was also recognized with a 2022 Travelers’ Choice Award, placing it among the top 10 percent of stays worldwide.
What truly caught national attention, however, is the home’s heartfelt tradition. The longtime owner requested that her handcrafted “Kayla’s Famous Atlantis House Key Lime Pie” recipe remain with the property for future owners to continue — a detail that transforms the home from simply a real estate listing into part of Key West storytelling.
As shared in the Realtor.com feature, this is more than a home — it is a legacy property rooted in hospitality, island culture, and authentic Key West living.
Read the full national feature here:
View the Realtor.com Story >>